E19's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[The Next Metroid]

COMPETE FAILURE

Overall-0
Sorry, but you have a complete failure. I wasn't going to wait that long for the movie to actually start.

Advice-x
Learn how to make a preloader. On Newgrounds search, type in "Preloader Tutorial" and watch one of them. Then, remake this flash, but with a preloader.

[Samus and the Metroid]

Best: Sound

Graphics-2
Well, they weren't your pics. So I don't really know what to say.

Style-2
You basically just motion tweened pictures around the screen.

Sound-4
There was music and that Metroid noise.

Violence-0
None

Interactivity-0
I don't count play buttons.

Humor-0
None

Overall-2
You bareely made it! I didn't blam you becuase I have seen way worse. You have been saved!

Advice-x
Make a flash with a story. It can still be a tribute... but it could have more of a point.

["The Mustache Contest"]

Best: Style

Graphics-7
Good drawings.

Style-8
Nice unique style. Also good how the fishes move by, changing the picture.

Sound-6
Good voices. I like the phone and pill noise.

Violence-0
None

Interactivity-0
I don't count play buttons.

Humor-4
Pretty funny. Weird.

Overall-6
I like your style.

Advice-x
Make another!

[Unmentionable Auction]

Best: Graphics, style, and sound

Graphics-8
Good drawings. Animation is good too.

Style-4
Kind of short. Not that short. But, kind of short. Bizarre story.

Sound-4
Good voices. Especially that cat.... I'll just call it "animal".

Violence-0
None. (Is sticking a lolipop up your butt violent in some way?)

Interactivity-0
I don't count play buttons.

Humor-3
Go "animal"! I like that thing.

Overall-6
Good drawings, weird concept overall.

Advice-x
None really. Just maybe work on your length.

[Mario: Fishy Water]

Best: Graphics and sound

Graphics-5
Good I guess. The background underwater was weird.

Style-2
Really short. I liked your play button though.

Sound-5
I didn't notice it too much. I don't know if that's bad or good.

Violence-3
Blood.

Interactivity-2
Buttons at top. But I don't count play buttons.

Humor-1
Well... maybe the first part was kinda funny.

Overall-2
When Mario was walking in the second scene, it was screwed up.

Advice-x
Try working on your story and length.

ch33ks responds:

Thanks for the review. Graphics, sound and humour was the only thing i aimed for. Length and story, that is covered in my new flash trust me. Expect it soon.

[Metroid: Rogue Formula]

Best: Graphics

Graphics-9
Way to go! To me you are the best spriter I've seen so far on Newgrounds! I gues it's becuase of your unique style. And I don't say this all the time. I never have!

Style-8
Again, exeptional spriting.

Sound-7
Good choice of music. It syncs good.

Violence-1
Barely any

Interactivity-0
I don't count play buttons

Humor-0
None

Overall-7
What game is Claire from? Did you pixel art her yourself?

cap123 responds:

:D thanks for the constructive review, and no, i didn't sprite claire myself, i think she was from a sonic game. I'm not sure though, sorry. :(

[Metroid The Attack Part 1]

Best: Graphics

Graphics-5
Your spriting was good, but when the bounty hunter fell backwards, it looked really lame. The steam was ugly.

Style-1
Okay. First of all, all of the other bounty hunters don't have the same suit as Samus. They have those grey ones. You (or someone else) could have changed the Samus sprites slightly to make them grey so that they resemble "not Samus".
Also, why did the Space Pirates have tons of Samus' one-of-a-kind ship? Major mess-up there.
And, since when were space pirates so hard to kill? You don't use power beam. You use missiles in some Metroid games and ice/spreader/plasma or whatever in MZM.

Sound-3
There could have been voices. The sound could have been downloaded of the internet, making it sound better. Did you download it off the internet?

Violence-1
Barely any

Interactivity-0
I don't count play buttons.

Humor-0
None

Overall-2
When you make the other, do a little research on Metroid first.

[Sheik Be A Woman]

Best: Graphics

Graphics-7
The drawings were good.

Style-5
Pretty short. But it had a story... kinda...

Sound-2
The voices were kind of muffled.

Violence-0
None

Interactivity-0
I don't count play buttons. Was there one..?.. I forgot.

Humor-4
Kinda funny.

Overall-4
Good, but it could have been longer.

[The Legend of Zelda]

Best: Graphics

Graphics-4
You used only a few symbols for the actual part of the movie!

Style-2
Way too short!

Sound-2
Eahhhh... I dunno.

Violence-1
Blood

Interactivity-1
I don't count play buttons. But Navi was there.

Humor-0
None

Overall-1
Too short! I hate it when I go to watch a flash, and I see... for example, your flash. I think it's the intro and I'm thinking "This could be good!" But, no. It stops. It's over. It's blammed by someone.
Humor-0

Overall-1

[Zelda's PRIDE force]

Best: Sound

Graphics-9
Really good drawings!

Style-7
Good movement and sync.

Sound-7
Good sound, except for some of the voices.

Violence-0
None

Interactivity-0
I don't count play buttons.

Humor-1
I liked the triforce idea.

Overall-6
I rated this good mostly becuase of how good the drawings are.